Should I DIY my website or hire a professional? The ultimate brain-scratcher for startups and beginners

You’ve got the idea. You’ve got the drive. You even have a name. Now, all that’s left is getting a website live to show the world. But wait—should you DIY it or call in a pro? For founders, startups, and freelancers trying to balance 100 tasks on a shoestring budget, this question is more loaded than your to-do list.

Let’s dive into the good, the bad, and the “why is this so complicated” of DIY websites and explore what might be your best middle ground.

‍

The appeal of DIY websites

Let’s be honest: the idea of rolling up your sleeves and creating your own website has a certain allure. It’s empowering, seems budget-friendly, and lets you be the master of your own digital presence. For founders, startups, and freelancers juggling tight budgets and even tighter schedules, DIY seems like the perfect solution.

Freedom and control

When you DIY your website, you’re the boss of every pixel and paragraph. Want that button to be neon green? Done. Need a quirky font that matches your personality? Easy. You don’t have to wait for anyone to schedule revisions or approve your ideas—it’s your vision, brought to life exactly how you see it.

Cost-saving

This is the big one for most DIY-ers. Hiring a professional designer or developer can feel like a major splurge when you’re working with limited resources. DIY platforms like Wix, Squarespace, or WordPress promise affordable plans and user-friendly tools that make creating a website seem as easy as dragging and dropping. For a fraction of the cost of hiring a pro, you can get something functional and get online quickly.

The satisfaction of doing it yourself

There’s something undeniably rewarding about building something with your own two hands—or, in this case, your own two clicks. The sense of accomplishment you feel when you hit “publish” and see your website live is hard to beat. It’s proof of your resourcefulness and determination. After all, as a startup founder or freelancer, solving problems is your bread and butter—so why not tackle your website too?

Great marketing by DIY website builders

DIY website platforms are masters of selling the dream. You’ve seen the ads: a young professional sits at their desk, smiling confidently at their computer screen. A few clicks later, the screen spins to reveal a jaw-dropping website that makes you think, “Wow, I need this in my life!”

These platforms will have you convinced that building a professional website is as simple as dragging and dropping a few elements into place. The pitch is undeniably attractive, and to their credit, they do provide plenty of resources to help you along the way.

But what they don’t show you in those glossy ads is the reality: the late-night Googling, the endless head-scratching over how to fix that one stubborn layout issue, or the hours spent figuring out why the mobile version of your site looks like it was designed for ants (in the immortal words of Zoolander).

So, before you grab your laptop and dive into designing, it’s worth pausing to ask yourself: is DIY really the best way to go for you and your business? The answer might not be as simple as the ads make it seem.

‍

The hidden challenges of DIY websites

The learning curve

The marketing for DIY platforms loves to use words like “easy” and “intuitive,” but that’s only true if you’ve done this before—or are willing to spend hours figuring it out. Sure, dragging and dropping elements onto a page seems simple enough, but what about when you need to tweak the layout or make a custom adjustment? Suddenly, you’re Googling terms like “CSS overrides,” “responsive design,” and “alt tags” at midnight.

And then there’s SEO. You might think your website is good to go after publishing, only to realize it’s buried on page 15 of search results. Learning the ins and outs of keywords, meta descriptions, and accessibility features can feel like taking a crash course in digital marketing.

The time drain

Let’s not sugarcoat it: DIY websites are time-intensive. What starts as a weekend project can spiral into weeks of trial and error. Between choosing the right platform, finding a template, customizing it, adding content, and troubleshooting technical glitches, you might find yourself sacrificing evenings and weekends just to get your site looking halfway decent.

As a founder or freelancer, your time is your most valuable asset. Every hour spent tinkering with a website is an hour you’re not focusing on your business, clients, or other critical tasks. And let’s face it—when you’re already stretched thin, that extra stress is the last thing you need.

The polish problem

Here’s the thing about DIY websites: no matter how much effort you put into them, they often still look like DIY websites. That’s not a knock on your abilities—it’s just that most people aren’t trained designers or developers. Achieving a truly professional, polished look is harder than it seems.

You’re the everything

When you DIY, you’re not just the designer and developer—you’re also the tech support team. If your website crashes, a plugin stops working, or your layout goes haywire, guess who’s on the hook to fix it? Spoiler: it’s you.

For non-tech-savvy folks, this can be a nightmare. Ever heard of DNS? How about SSL, responsive breakpoints, or Google PageSpeed Insights? Struggling with speed optimization to achieve a decent score on PageSpeed Insights is a pain many DIY-ers know too well. (If this sounds familiar, check out my blog post on optimizing website speed for actionable tips.)

Before you know it, you’re spending hours in forums trying to figure out what “caching issues” mean or why your site’s load time feels like a trip back to the dial-up era. It’s enough to make even the most determined DIY-er want to throw in the towel.

‍

The case for hiring a professional

Custom design that matches your vision

When you hire a pro, you’re getting a website tailored to your brand, audience, and goals. No cookie-cutter templates or layouts here; instead, you’ll have a site that feels uniquely “you.”

Expertise you just can’t DIY

Designing a website isn’t just about making it look good—it’s about making it work. User experience (UX) plays a massive role in how visitors interact with your site. Professionals know how to make your website feel intuitive and effective, ensuring visitors can easily find what they’re looking for and take the actions you want them to take.

It’s dangerous (and inaccurate) to assume that whatever you put on a webpage will automatically create the outcome you desire. A professional ensures your website is designed with purpose, combining aesthetics, usability, and strategy in a way DIY platforms rarely match.

Save time (and your sanity)

Hiring a professional isn’t just an investment in skills—it’s an investment in time saved. While you focus on running your business, your designer is busy creating a website that works as hard as you do.

Scalability for the future

A professionally built website is like a well-laid foundation—it’s ready to grow with your business. Need to add an e-commerce store later? Expand into multiple languages? Integrate advanced tools or custom features? A custom-built site can handle these demands with ease, unlike many DIY platforms that come with limitations.

The price tag reality

Yes, hiring a professional costs more upfront. But when you factor in the long-term benefits—fewer headaches, better functionality, and the ability to scale—it’s often a smart investment. A good website can pay for itself through increased credibility, higher conversion rates, and better customer retention.

That said, custom websites can take weeks or months to build, and the costs might be more than you’re willing or able to spend right now. So, where does that leave you? Somewhere in the middle. Enter: the perfect solution.

‍

The perfect solution: Website templates

What if you could save time, money, and hassle while still getting a website that looks professional? That’s where website templates come in.

Common criticisms

Hear me out. You’ve probably heard all the arguments against website templates:

• “They’re cookie-cutter.”
• “Your site will look like everyone else’s.”
• “You can’t stand out with a template.”

And sure, templates are pre-designed—so yes, if you don’t customize them, they might not fully capture your brand’s uniqueness. But does that mean your site will automatically blend into the crowd? Not necessarily.

Why templates are still a smart choice

What these criticisms often miss is that templates are designed to simplify website creation for non-tech beginners. You don’t need to be a coding expert or a professional designer to use them effectively. A high-quality template gives you a head start, saving you from the steep learning curve of starting from scratch.

Even with minimal customization, a well-chosen template can look polished, professional, and on-brand. And if you want to go the extra mile, most templates allow for tweaks that let you infuse your personality or brand identity into the design.

Cost-effective, without looking cheap

High-quality website templates are designed by professionals, which means you get the benefit of expert design at a fraction of the cost. For under $100—or sometimes even free—you can find templates that rival custom-built websites in appearance.

Save time and get online faster

When you’re racing against the clock, templates are a lifesaver. Instead of starting from scratch, you can choose a template that fits your needs and customize it with your content, colors, and branding. What might take weeks with a custom build can often be done in a day or two with a good template.

A professional look, out of the box

The best templates are built with modern design trends and user experience in mind. They’re responsive, meaning they work well on mobile and desktop, and often come with built-in features like contact forms, galleries, or call-to-action sections.

Customizable to fit your brand

While templates provide a strong starting point, they’re also highly customizable. Most platforms let you tweak fonts, colors, images, and layouts to better reflect your unique brand. With a little effort, you can make a template feel just as personalized as a custom site—without the hefty price tag.

Scalable for growth

Starting with a template doesn’t mean you’re locked into it forever. As your business grows, templates often allow for additional features and functionality. And when you’re ready to upgrade to a custom design, your template-based site can serve as a solid stepping stone.

‍

Choosing the right template

All that being said, not all templates are created equal. And more importantly, not just any template will work for your business. Choosing the right template is one of the most important decisions you’ll make—it sets the foundation for your website’s success.

To help you navigate this crucial step, I’ve created a detailed guide on Choosing the Right Template. It’s packed with tips to ensure you pick a template that not only looks great but also serves your unique business needs.

‍

Finding the right balance

Deciding between DIY, hiring a professional, and using a template ultimately comes down to your priorities: time, budget, and the impression you want to make.

DIY is tempting but comes with challenges that can drain your time and energy. Hiring a professional is ideal but might be out of reach for many early-stage businesses. Templates, on the other hand, offer the best of both worlds—a quick, affordable way to get online with a professional-looking website that doesn’t break the bank.

Your website doesn’t have to be perfect on day one. It just needs to be live, functional, and ready to evolve as your business grows. A well-designed template is the perfect place to start—and who knows? It might just be all you need to make a lasting impression.